(The Dialog is an unbiased, nonprofit supply of reports, evaluation, and commentary from educational consultants.)
(CHAT) Editor’s Observe: This text comprises plot spoilers for The Whale.
Earlier than I noticed The Whale, I knew it was a film a few man named Charlie, who weighs over 600 kilos, is grieving the demise of his accomplice, and is trapped in his residence due to his weight.
I additionally knew that “The Whale” had attracted a number of criticism, anger, disgust and accusations of exploitation. Regardless of the controversy, Brendan Fraser’s efficiency was extremely praised and he was nominated for Finest Actor on the ninety fifth Academy Awards.
However what I did not know was that this film would make me cry. As I left the theater, I felt my fats physique transfer within the car parking zone, and I started to really feel what I usually do once I see my reflection within the mirror: horrible.
In my analysis on fats characters in widespread tradition, I level out how a fats character often must shed extra pounds to be able to be accepted or beloved.
And in “The Whale” Charlie would not shed extra pounds; the transformation goes in the other way: it grows larger and larger, undergoes a gradual and painful bodily collapse. As I watched the movie, I started to understand with a way of dread that “The Whale” has no plans to revive this picture. Weight problems was the subject and the second.
I started to understand that this movie was neither a melodrama nor an uplifting story of redemption; To me, The Whale is a physique horror movie that exploits the concern and disgust folks really feel in the direction of being fats.
The physique is sort of a monster
Physique horror is a subgenre of horror movies that depict the destruction, degeneration, or mutation of the human physique. These movies are designed to frustrate the viewers, and the primary character usually turns into the monster of the story as his physique turns into an increasing number of hideous.
Director David Cronenberg popularized this subgenre in movies corresponding to “The Fly”, “Tishiriril”, “Videodrome” and “Rabies”.
A remake of the 1958 movie of the identical identify, The Fly tells the story of a scientist named Seth Brundle who fuses his DNA with that of a typical housefly. Over the course of the movie, he progressively transforms right into a hideous creature nicknamed “Brundlefly”. One other significantly disturbing physique horror movie is Tusk, the place a person obsessive about walruses finally ends up stealing a brutal podcaster and dismembering it to show it right into a walrus.
There’s something viscerally disturbing about seeing the human physique distorted in physique horror movies, whether or not by a parasitic alien, a mutated virus, or the sadistic compulsions of a mad scientist.
The whale says that Charlie is a monster, even when he deserves pity.
Just like the drunken self-experimenter Seth Brundle, Charlie frequently eats fried hen, pizza, and submarines—which is straight liable for Charlie’s morbid weight problems.
Seeing Charlie’s gradual bodily disintegration is like watching a automotive crash in gradual movement; You possibly can’t look when you already know it is best to. He can hardly stand on his toes and is unable to carry out even the only of duties, corresponding to selecting issues up from the ground. In some scenes, the digicam rests on Charlie’s swollen intestine, swollen calves, or sweat-soaked garments, inviting the viewers to step again.
In physique horror, there isn’t a turning again; harm is finished. Whereas not each modified physique horror character dies, many do.
Ultimately, Charlie’s physique destroys him.
Until flesh do us half
Movie critic Robin Wooden famously argued that “the true theme of the horror style is the wrestle for recognition of all that our civilization represses and suppresses.”
In a thin-obsessed tradition, fatness has grow to be a monster of its personal. Regardless of the physique positivity motion, fats individuals are nonetheless usually considered as unattractive and irregular, and usually tend to be discriminated towards within the office, stigmatized by medical doctors, and convicted by juries.
In 2012, sociologist Francis Ray White wrote that “weight problems is more and more seen as anti-social” – “to be eradicated for the sake of a livable future”. When speaking about weight problems as an “epidemic,” White notes, it reinforces the concept that weight problems is a illness that must be handled, and that fats individuals are carriers of the illness, not folks.
Within the last moments of The Whale, the viewers witnesses the tip of Charlie’s life: He vividly remembers the time when he was comfortable on the seashore along with his daughter, full of affection for all times. As he dies, he lastly rises into the air, free of his monstrous burden of flesh.
That is the one time within the movie that he seems weightless; certainly, it’s the character’s solely second of freedom.
However the monster itself – fatness – lives on.
The director of the movie, Darren Aronofsky, stated that his movie is an “train in empathy”.
But when empathy is the flexibility to grasp and share the sentiments of one other, why did I go away my physique as an irreplaceable monster? I’m not alone on this concern; critic Roxane Homosexual known as The Whale a “carnival sideshow” and “emotionally devastating”. In response to Homosexual, “The Whale” describes weight problems as “a vile factor to be averted in any respect prices.”
He might painting a monster. He might describe me.
This text is republished from The Dialog below a Inventive Commons license. Learn the unique article right here: https://theconversation.com/the-whale-is-a-horror-film-that-taps-into-our-fear-of-fatness-197859.
